The Broan-NuTone 413001 and the CIARRA CAS75502 are aimed at completely different buyers. At $89, the Broan-NuTone is a lightweight, ductless under-cabinet hood backed by more than 20,000 ratings and a 4.6-star average, a track record that is hard to argue with at that price. The CIARRA CAS75502 costs $302.54, mounts to the wall as a chimney-style hood, and exhausts cooking air outside at 650 CFM with touch-and-gesture controls. The fundamental divide is ventilation type: the Broan-NuTone recirculates air through a charcoal filter and works without any ductwork, while the CIARRA vents grease and steam out of the house entirely. Matching the right one to your kitchen comes down to whether you have, or can add, a duct run.
The CIARRA CAS75502 wins for kitchens with existing ductwork and cooks who need real exhaust power; the Broan-NuTone 413001 wins for ductless setups, tight budgets, and easy no-fuss installation.
| Spec | Broan-NuTone 413001 Range Hood | CIARRA CAS75502 Range Hood |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $89.00 | $302.54 |
| Rating | ||
| Mounting | Under Cabinet Mount | Wall Mount |
| Ventilation | Recirculation | Exhaust |
| Fan speeds | 2 | 3 |
| Filter | Charcoal | Mesh |
| Width | 30.0 in | 29.53 in |
| Controls | Push Button | Touch & Gesture |
| Finish | White | Polished |
| Color | White | Silver |
| Dimensions | 6 X 30 X 17.5 In | 18.5 X 29.53 X 19.45 In |
| Weight | 10.0 lb | 34.39 lb |
| Voltage | 120 Volts | 120 Volts (Ac) |
The Broan-NuTone 413001 is a 30-inch under-cabinet hood that weighs just 10 pounds and needs no duct connection. It pulls air through a charcoal filter to trap grease and odors, then returns the air to the kitchen, which suits older homes, rentals, or spaces where cutting through walls or ceilings for ductwork is not practical. Push-button controls give you two fan speeds. The white finish matches traditional kitchen cabinetry, though it will look out of place in a stainless-steel kitchen. At $89 with a 4.6-star rating from over 20,000 buyers, it is one of the most proven budget hood options on the market.
Buy this if: The Broan-NuTone 413001 is the right call for renters, homeowners without existing ductwork, or anyone replacing a tired old hood without taking on a renovation project. It is also a practical choice for a garage kitchen, vacation cabin, or any secondary cooking space where ductless filtering is acceptable and installation simplicity matters.
Check price on Amazon
The CIARRA CAS75502 is a 29.53-inch wall-mount chimney hood that actively exhausts smoke and grease outside at 650 CFM. Its polished silver finish and rising chimney stack add a design element above the range rather than hiding under a cabinet. Touch-and-gesture controls and three fan speeds give you more precision than a basic two-speed unit. The mesh filter handles grease before air moves through the duct. At 34.39 pounds and 18.5 inches deep, it requires a proper wall mount and a duct run, but the payoff is meaningful ventilation performance. With 4.4 stars across 3,100 reviews, buyers are generally satisfied with its build and airflow.
Buy this if: The CIARRA CAS75502 suits homeowners who cook on gas ranges or at high heat and want real exhaust ventilation rather than recirculated filtered air. It is a good fit for kitchens that already have a wall duct or where the owner is willing to add one, and for buyers who want a chimney-style visual anchor above the range without stepping into premium-brand pricing.
Check price on AmazonThe 413001 recirculates air through a charcoal filter rather than exhausting it outside, so it traps some grease and dampens odors but does not remove smoke or steam from the kitchen the way a ducted hood does. For light everyday cooking that is often sufficient, but if you fry frequently or cook on high heat, you will notice smoke and steam lingering in the room. A ducted exhaust hood like the CIARRA CAS75502 handles those situations far more effectively.
The CIARRA CAS75502 is designed and rated as an exhaust hood, meaning it is built to push air through a duct to the outside. Its spec does not list a convertible or ductless option, unlike the Broan-NuTone 413001 which is built specifically for recirculation. You should budget for a duct run before purchasing the CIARRA; running it without one would leave exhaust air with nowhere to go.
The Broan-NuTone 413001 is one of the simpler range hood installs available, it weighs 10 pounds, brackets under an existing cabinet, and requires no duct work. Most homeowners can complete it with basic hand tools in under an hour. The CIARRA CAS75502 is a different job: at 34.39 pounds it needs solid wall anchoring, and the duct run to an exterior wall adds planning time and likely contractor involvement if you are not comfortable with that kind of work.
That depends on what you need. The Broan-NuTone 413001 at $89 does exactly what it is designed to do: ductless odor filtering at low cost. The CIARRA CAS75502 at $302.54 gives you 650 CFM of true exhaust ventilation, a wall-mount chimney design, touch-and-gesture controls, and three fan speeds. If your home has ductwork and you cook often at high heat, the CIARRA's performance difference over a recirculating hood is real. If you do not have ductwork and just need basic odor control, the Broan-NuTone is the sensible choice.